Knowledgebase Search

Question:

Does COMPRESS consider vortex shedding? How do I turn vortex shedding on in COMPRESS?

Answer:

COMPRESS provides options to account for the action of vortex shedding. The designer must initiate the vortex shedding analysis when desired. To do so: Edit the Wind Code and click the button labeled "Vortex Shedding / Damping Coefficients"; the Vortex Shedding Calculations dialog will be displayed. "Check" the conditions for which the vortex shedding analysis should be performed (eg: Operating, Empty, and Vacuum).

When the wind vortex shedding option is applied COMPRESS first determines the critical wind speed of the vessel. If this is greater than the design wind speed then no further analysis is performed because the necessary forcing condition for vortex shedding would not be encountered. If the critical wind speed is less than the design wind speed, COMPRESS uses the method described in the National Building Code (NBC) of Canada - 1995 to perform an analysis for the additional loads imposed on the vessel by the vortex shedding condition.

The vortex shedding analysis defined in the NBC applies a static load to the top 1/3 height of the vessel in a direction perpendicular to the wind. The static load is determined based on the vessel geometry, dynamic characteristics (natural frequency) and the critical wind speed.

When the critical wind speed is less than the design wind speed COMPRESS performs additional calculations to determine the bending moments in the vessel due to the combined effect of the additional lateral force due to vortex shedding and the basic wind load corresponding to the critical wind speed. Additional summary tables are provided to report the wind shear, bending moment and deflection due to this load condition. In "Design Mode", COMPRESS will increase shell thicknesses if necessary to maintain the calculated stresses at or below the allowable stress.

Note that the vortex shedding calculations reported are based on forces resulting from a wind speed corresponding to the critical wind speed. For example, if the design wind speed is 90 miles per hour (mph) but the critical wind speed is only 20 mph, then the results (wind shear, bending moment, deflection) are calculated based on the 20 mph critical wind speed in combination with an additional vortex shedding force applied normal to the wind flow. Thus there is no "mixing" of design wind speed of 90 mph with vortex shedding forces applied at 20 mph.

If the deflection due to wind (with or without vortex shedding action) exceeds the maximum specified in the Wind Code dialog and design mode is used, COMPRESS will automatically increase the shell and skirt thicknesses so as to increase the moment of inertia to a value so that the deflection is within the specified limits.

See these related technical papers on the Codeware website: